trans law

Taro akan rediyo, dubban tweets, posts a cikin dukkanin kafofin watsa labaru da ra'ayoyi daban-daban game da Dokar Trans a Spain, kuma da alama cewa babu wani abu da ya bayyana har yanzu. Lokacin da na karanta ko sauraron ra'ayoyi daban-daban ko kuma shiga cikin wasu muhawara, a ƙarshe na lura cewa ra'ayi na gaske yana cikin girgije kuma komai yana ƙarewa a cikin ɓoye na zagi mai ban mamaki. millenials (" ka na a tafsiri”, misali) kuma mu daina sauraron wanda ke gabanmu. Yayi nisa sosai da son mata da soriyar da muka dade muna fama da ita.

Amma menene dokar Trans Law ke nema? Me ya sa ake yawan muhawara? A ina ya kamata a sanya hankalin hankali? Bari mu yi taƙaitaccen taƙaitaccen bayani kuma mu sake duba ra’ayoyi daban-daban ta yadda kowa zai iya, aƙalla, ya fahimci ɗaya daga cikin batutuwan da suka fi jawo cece-kuce a fage.

Anan daftarin dokar Trans

Manufofin Dokar Trans

Dokar Trans tana neman (ko ya kamata a nema) don ba da duk haƙƙoƙin ga mutanen da ke wucewa, haɓaka daidaito da kawo ƙarshen wariya.

A halin yanzu, akwai kawai daftarin aiki, don haka har yanzu ba a yarda da shi a matsayin doka ba.

Ƙungiyar trans sun nemi "depatologization na jima'i" da "ƙaddamar da jinsi", kuma wannan shine abin da Doka ta ba su. To, me yasa sashin mata ba a gamsu ba?

Daga abin da na ji a cikin muhawarar, duk ya samo asali ne daga manufar jinsi. Babu wani mai ra'ayin mata da ya fito fili ya ce (kuma ba na tsammanin za su yi tunanin haka) cewa mutanen trans bai kamata a rufe su da doka ba, kada su sami 'yancin irin na matan cisgender, ko kuma kada su zama mata.

" Jinsi ba ainihin asali ba ne, ginin al'adu ne wanda ke sanya ayyuka da matsayi dangane da jima'i," in ji Ángeles Álvarez, tsohon mataimakin PSOE (La Vanguardia, 2021). A takaice dai, bayar da shawarar tantance kan jinsi bisa doka gane cewa nau'ikan suna wanzu kuma dole ne a kiyaye su ta hanyar doka. A saboda wannan dalili, wani ɓangare na motsi na mata ba ya yarda da fasaha da aka yi amfani da shi a cikin daftarin aiki inda ake amfani da "gano kai na jinsi" maimakon "gano kai na jima'i".

Mutumin da aka haifa tare da jima'i wanda ba sa jin dadi ko gano shi mutum ne mai jima'i. Misali, macen da aka yi jima'i ita ce wadda aka haifa da azzakari kuma tana jin kamar mace. Yanzu, za ku iya ko ba za ku iya aiki da canza na'urar wasan ku ba idan kuna so.

Amma menene ya zama transgender? Shin wannan ra'ayi ba shine musabbabin wannan muhawara ba? Kasancewa transgender yana nufin rashin jin daɗi da jinsin da al'umma suka sanya. Shin macen da aka haifa da al'aura, amma ba ta yarda da ayyukan da aka dora mata ba (tufafi ta hanyar X, sanya kayan shafa, gyaran fuska, da sauransu) ko kuma namijin da aka haifa da azzakari. kuma ba ya so ya shiga cikin transgender sanya ayyukan maza waɗanda muka saba da su?

Ta hanyar ma'anar, i. Za su kasance. Kuma, a fili, dole ne a kiyaye su ta hanyar doka.

Transsexual da dysphoria

Saboda haka, bin zaren, matsalar ta taso a cikin kalmomin "Ina jin kamar mace" ko "Ina jin kamar namiji". Mace mai jima'i, ko ta yanke shawarar yin tiyata ko a'a. tana jin ita mace ce. Yana jin an haife shi a jikin da bai gamsu da shi ba. Kuna jin cewa jima'i da aka haife ku ba naku ba ne. Kuma wannan shi ne abin da aka sani da "dysphoria" ko "rashin daidaituwa" [a wasu wuraren yana tare da “na jinsi” amma bai kamata ya zama “na jima’i ba”?].

A cikin 2018, an lalata wannan dysphoria a matsayin "rashin lafiyar hankali" ta Hukumar Lafiya ta Duniya (WHO), amma an bar shi a cikin nau'in "lalacewar jima'i"; ta yadda za a daina la'akari da shi a matsayin ciwon zuciya kuma ya zama ciwon jiki.

Koyaya, tare da daftarin sabuwar dokar Trans, an yi niyya don kawar da dysphoria gaba ɗaya.

Ga wani daga cikin manyan batutuwan muhawarar. Shin dysphoria cuta ce ta jiki? Me yasa yawan tsoron kalmar "cuta"? Shin matsalar a cikin ma'anar "cututtuka"?

Ba wanda yake so ya ji rashin lafiya. Ba wanda yake son a nuna shi da yatsan wani. Ba wanda yake son a dube shi da tausayi. Yana da cikakkiyar fahimta. Idan kuma batun sanya wa wannan rukunin suna “marasa lafiya” ya cutar da su, kuma cutar da su ya amfane su, ku ci gaba.

Duk da haka, an soki cewa cire shi daga wannan jerin cututtuka na lalata jima'i na iya haifar da mummunan sakamako ga al'ummar trans kanta. Idan ba a yi la'akari da cutar ba, shin za su iya rasa haƙƙin lafiyar su idan ya zo ga son hormones ko tiyata? Wannan ita ce tambayar da wadancan mata masu adawa da wannan batu suka yi a daftarin.

Transsexuality: cuta ko a'a

Idan, da gaske, matsalar ta ta'allaka ne a cikin harshe da kuma cikin amfani da kalmar cuta, kuma gaskiyar daina la'akari da haka ba zai haifar da mummunan sakamako a kansu ba, ba za a sake yin magana ba. A daina kiran cutar.

RAE (wanda bai kamata a ambaci sunansa kamar Allah Maɗaukaki ba, amma don haɗa ma'anar kawai) ya bayyana cutar da cewa. Ƙara ko žasa mai tsanani rashin lafiya. Don haka, ana iya ɗaukarsa a matsayin cuta idan aka haife shi tare da sashin jima'i wanda ba a gano shi ba yana cutar da lafiyar mutum ta kowace hanya.

Michael First, wani likitan kwakwalwa a U. de Colombia (Amurka) ya tabbatar da haka haɗa mutanen trans zuwa tabin hankali yana da illa gaba ɗaya saboda babban abin kunya da ke akwai game da waɗannan cututtuka, amma cewa "ba za a iya cire shi gaba daya daga ICD 11 ba, tun da masu jima'i suna buƙatar hanyoyin likita (...) Suna kuma buƙatar tiyata ko hanyoyin kwantar da hankali, don haka, idan ba su da wani magani. ganewar asali, waɗannan mutanen za a iya barin su ba tare da ɗaukar hoto ba. Tambayar ta ainihi ba ita ce ko za a iya cire rashin daidaituwa na jinsi daga ICD ba, amma inda za a iya sake komawa ", in ji ƙwararrun (La Tercera, 2018).

Ƙaddamar da kai ba tare da rahoton likita ba

Wani kuma wanda aka fi yabawa kuma, a lokaci guda, ana sukar batutuwan daftarin shine na "tsarin kai na jinsi ba tare da buƙatar rahoton likita ba".

Masu sukar hakan sun nuna cewa ba tare da buƙatar ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun za ta tantance cewa wannan mutumin ba ya yin jima’i ko kuma a’a, kowane mutum zai iya zuwa wurin yin rajista. Canja jinsin ku akan takaddar shaidar ku.

Idan kuna tunanin sanyi, bai kamata komai ya faɗi ba ko bai sanya DNI ba. Bai kamata a ba da dacewa ga jima'i ga kowane nau'in tsari ba tunda abin da ake nema shine daidaito. A gaskiya ma, ba zai fi dacewa kada a ci gaba da ba da rahoton jima'i a kowace hukuma ba?

Babu shakka, don dalilai masu amfani yana da mahimmanci. A Spain, aƙalla, rashin daidaituwa ta hanyar jima'i yana ci gaba da kasancewa, tashin hankali na jima'i yana ci gaba da kasancewa a matakin jama'a da masu zaman kansu.

Bugu da kari, akwai ayyuka da dole ne a yarda da mafi ƙanƙanta na mata ko maza don samun daidaiton ƙima.

A irin wannan yanayi, masu sukar dokar sun ce kowa zai iya zuwa wurin rajista don canza jima'i don yin hakan. yi amfani da fa'idar kasancewa da sauran jima'i. Yana da wuya a gare ni in yi tunanin hakan zai iya faruwa; amma, da rashin alheri, a cikin kasar na picaresque duk abin da zai yiwu.

Sai dai masu kare daftarin sun yi ishara da mafi karancin adadin wadannan kararraki na yaudara da za a yi.

Hakazalika, ana iya guje wa wannan tare da rahoton likita wanda ke nuna cewa wannan mutumin yana da dysphoria (ko cuta ko a'a). Wanda ya kai mu babu makawa zuwa ga batu da ya gabata.

Muhawara ta Doka

Kamar yadda muke iya gani, muhawara ce mai ruɗani. Ina maimaita cewa ba za mu iya rasa maƙasudi na ƙarshe kuma na gaske ba, wanda shine cimma daidaito na gaske ga kowa da kowa, ba tare da la'akari da jima'i ba, ba tare da la'akari da tsarin haihuwa da aka haife ku ba, ba tare da nuna bambanci ba kuma ba tare da kowa ya yanke shawara ga kowa yadda yake ji ba, amma inda muke. duk sunyi la'akari da waɗannan batutuwa a cikin zurfi, ba tare da jin tsoron shakka, tambaya, yin muhawara da koyo ba.

➳ Ga wata muhawara akan karuwanci

LITTAFI MAI TSARKI

FERNÁNDEZ CANDIAL, A. (Fabrairu 5, 2021) Tsarin doka: nazari guda biyu masu karo da juna. La Vanguardia. An warke a: https://www.lavanguardia.com/vida/20210307/6265037/ley-trans-dos-analisis-contrapuestos.html

SEPÚLVEDA, YÁÑEZ Y SILVA (June 18, 2018) Rashin jima'i: daga rashin hankali zuwa rashin lafiyar jima'i, a cewar WHO.  Na uku. An warke a: https://www.latercera.com/tendencias/noticia/transexualidad-trastorno-mental-enfermedad-sexual-segun-la-oms/211488/#:~:text=Ser%20transexual%20ya%20no%20es%20un%20trastorno%20de%20salud%20mental.&text=Con%20este%20cambio%2C%20pierde%20la,g%C3%A9nero%20que%20siente%20la%20persona.

ÁLVAREZ, P. (Fabrairu 7, 2021) The 'trans law' daga mabanbanta kusurwoyi. Kasar. An warke a: https://elpais.com/sociedad/2021-02-06/la-ley-trans-desde-angulos-opuestos.html


Kasance na farko don yin sharhi

Bar tsokaci

Your email address ba za a buga. Bukata filayen suna alama da *

*

*

  1. Hakkin bayanan: Actualidad Blog
  2. Manufar bayanan: Sarrafa SPAM, sarrafa sharhi.
  3. Halacci: Yarda da yarda
  4. Sadarwar bayanan: Ba za a sanar da wasu bayanan ga wasu kamfanoni ba sai ta hanyar wajibcin doka.
  5. Ajiye bayanai: Bayanin yanar gizo wanda Occentus Networks (EU) suka dauki nauyi
  6. Hakkoki: A kowane lokaci zaka iyakance, dawo da share bayanan ka.